Deviant Login Shop  Join deviantART for FREE Take the Tour

I vs II 

59%
683 deviants said II The Rise of a Planet II by taenaron
41%
475 deviants said I The Rise of a Planet by taenaron

Devious Comments

:iconrv-tide:
RV-TIDE Feb 12, 2010  Professional Digital Artist
I prefer the 2nd one, but heck! I'd buy either lol, keep up the work man.
Reply
:iconstarfire-013:
I like the general composition of II better, but I do think the sky and clouds in I are much better.
Reply
:iconjollygreenjustin:
JollyGreenJustin Jan 28, 2010  Hobbyist Photographer
Compositionally the second is better.
Reply
:iconovertkill-ud:
Number 1. Looks more natural to me, thus more realistic. :)
Reply
:iconanidem:
Anidem Jan 28, 2010
the stars in number two is what did it for me. It had a more "natural" feel of space than in number one
Reply
:iconezio:
The second is beautiful too, but i think the first one was better, more "powerful" clouds and atmosfera :)
Bye God! :D
Reply
:iconbeyond-matter:
Beyond-Matter Jan 28, 2010  Student Writer
Though both are incredible pieces, I think the second version better plays on the sense of realism. I feel like I'm looking at a photograph.
Reply
:iconerikshoemaker:
ErikShoemaker Jan 28, 2010  Hobbyist Digital Artist
technisch gesehen eindeutig #2
Reply
:icontherealwazzar:
I prefer 2 in the closeup detail, but 1 looks better in smallview.
Reply
:iconbattlefield1010:
I voted for the first one just because I like the atmosphere of the picture more than the second. Though, the clouds in the second one look better than in the first, so it was quite a tough choice to make actually. :) Both are nice
Reply
Add a Comment:
 

Poll History